| Pick | Cody Raue | Stats | Steve Wheeler | Stats | Winner | Pick | Dayton Hansen | Stats | Edward Fingel | Stats | Winner | |
| QB | Drew Brees | 285 | Ben Roethlisberger | 281 | Cody | QB | Ben Roethlisberger | 281 | Tom Brady | 298 | Edward | |
| RB | LeSean McCoy | 50 | LeSean McCoy | 50 | TIE | RB | Alex Collins | 19 | Jamaal Williams | 30 | Edward | |
| WR | Antonio Brown | 24 | JuJu Smith-Schuster | 114 | Steve | WR | Julio Jones | 54 | Antonio Brown | 24 | Dayton | |
| TE | Zach Miller | 0 | Hunter Henry | 0 | TIE | TE | Travis Kelce | 0 | Rob Gronkowski | 0 | TIE | |
| K | Justin Tucker | 2 | Travis Coons | 0 | Cody | K | Jake Elliott | 2 | Robbie Gould | 6 | Edward | |
| DEF | Ravens | 10 | Bills | 16 | Cody | DEF | Vikings | 7 | Saints | 19 | Dayton | |
| MNF Score | 50 | 55 | MNF Score | 52 | 51 | |||||||
| Head-to-Head Winner: | Cody wins 3-1 | Head-to-Head Winner: | Edward wins 3-2 | |||||||||
| Pick | Bethany Raue | Stats | Krysta Shipman | Stats | Winner | Pick | Ashley Futch | Stats | Lalita Farr | Stats | Winner | |
| QB | Ben Roethlisberger | 281 | Ben Roethlisberger | 281 | TIE | QB | Ben Roethlisberger | 281 | Ben Roethlisberger | 281 | TIE | |
| RB | Melvin Gordon | 78 | LeSean McCoy | 50 | Bethany | RB | LeSean McCoy | 50 | LeSean McCoy | 50 | TIE | |
| WR | Julio Jones | 54 | Antonio Brown | 24 | Bethany | WR | Julio Jones | 54 | Keenan Allen | 54 | TIE | |
| TE | Rob Gronkowski | 0 | Rob Gronkowski | 0 | TIE | TE | Rob Gronkowski | 0 | Rob Gronkowski | 0 | TIE | |
| K | Jake Elliott | 2 | Justin Tucker | 2 | TIE | K | Matt Bryant | 1 | Jake Elliott | 2 | Lalita | |
| DEF | Saints | 19 | Vikings | 7 | Krysta | DEF | Jaguars | 7 | Ravens | 10 | Ashley | |
| MNF Score | 49 | 47 | MNF Score | 51 | 56 | |||||||
| Head-to-Head Winner: | Bethany wins 2-1 | Head-to-Head Winner: | Ashley wins 1-1 with Longest FG tie-breaker | |||||||||